Meta recently announced that by 2026, it will be able to handle all online advertising for its clients, lock, stock and barrel, from ideation to campaign management. Meanwhile, Amazon and Google continue to develop new tools to help advertisers automate more creative work on their own platforms. These are the latest examples of Big Tech offering to do all your ad heavy lifting with AI. Should you take them up on the offer?
In a word, No.
AI can be a powerful partner. But no matter how effective AI becomes, human beings should never hand over the keys. Why? Because full automation carries unacceptable risks, from brand damage to regulatory exposure. The best advertisers don’t outsource strategy and storytelling to machines. They use AI to enhance their capabilities but not replace them.
Here’s why that difference matters.
The Costs of “Set It and Forget It”
Big Tech makes AI advertising sound like an “easy button.” But behind the scenes, full automation with tools like Google’s Performance Max can lead to inefficiencies and remain unproven in our view. The more automated the campaign, the more risk you undertake that the tools won’t deliver what you had hoped for.
Privacy and Compliance Nightmares
AI operates on a massive amount of data. But when left unchecked, they can expose brands to serious privacy violations. Automated platforms often track users’ locations, behaviors, and preferences in ways that don’t always comply with evolving laws like GDPR or the California Consumer Privacy Act.
And regulators are watching. In Europe, Italy’s data protection agency recently blocked an AI-powered advertising tool over lack of transparency about data use. In the U.S., the FTC has begun cracking down on companies that rely on AI systems that unintentionally discriminate or mishandle sensitive data.
Handing over control to AI means trusting that your vendors are doing everything right, which can create an unacceptable risk.
AI Bias Is Real and Dangerous
When you let AI make the decisions, you’re also letting it inherit your biases. Or worse, build new ones.
Facebook’s ad algorithm has come under fire for systematic bias. Dynamic pricing tools may show different prices to users based on race, location, or gender. Targeting systems may systematically exclude entire communities. If left unchecked, these biases undermine your brand’s values and expose you to regulatory action.
You might not see the problem, but that’s the point. Many affected users never know they were excluded.
You Lose Your Voice and Your Edge
AI is incredibly efficient at remixing what’s already out there. But it doesn’t innovate. It doesn’t surprise. And it doesn’t create culture.
When platforms like Meta or Google automate both the creation and delivery of ads, your brand voice gets flattened into something algorithm-friendly. Instead of standing out, you start sounding just like everyone else.
This homogenization effect erodes authenticity and makes it harder for consumers to connect with your brand. Your story becomes a set of data points—and your messaging loses its human touch. Over time, you risk becoming indistinguishable from your competitors.
Worse still, you lose control. As Meta builds a feedback loop where its AI both creates and optimizes your ads, the platform, not you, becomes the author of your brand.
When AI Fails, It Fails Spectacularly
You’ve likely seen examples of AI going off the rails. These failures often stem from systems that can’t grasp emotional nuance, cultural context, or moral responsibility.
In 2024, Air Canada’s chatbot made headlines for inventing a refund policy out of thin air. A customer relied on the information, only to have the airline refuse the refund until a court intervened. The judge held the company accountable, not the bot.
Google’s Gemini AI generated historically inaccurate and racially skewed images, triggering a public backlash. Despite rapid responses from Google, the episode showed how easily generative AI can distort facts in the absence of editorial judgment.
The FTC also stepped in last year, fining DoNotPay for falsely advertising its AI-powered legal assistant as a real lawyer. The bot promised more than it could deliver, eroding consumer trust and sparking broader questions about transparency in AI marketing.
When you remove humans from the loop, these failures are inevitable.
How to Use AI the Right Way
None of this means you should avoid AI. On the contrary, AI is indispensable in modern advertising. But its role should be that of a tool, not the pilot.
Here’s how to use AI the smart way:
- Keep humans in charge. Let AI crunch the numbers and test creative variations. But keep people in control of the brand message, media mix, and campaign goals. AI excels at repetitive tasks like A/B testing, bid optimization, and reporting. But even then, humans need to monitor the results you’re getting from AI-driven campaigns and be prepared to step in and make mid-course corrections.
- Protect your brand voice. Train AI tools with your tone, style, and guidelines. Never let generic prompts determine how your brand sounds. Final approval for all messaging should come from human reviewers.
- Monitor for bias. Audit AI-generated content regularly. Make sure ads are inclusive and fair. Don’t assume the algorithm is neutral. Build in human review at every stage.
- Double down on compliance. Stay informed about evolving data laws. Choose partners who can demonstrate compliance. Avoid tools that operate like black boxes. Transparency is a must.
- Expect AI to support, not replace, creativity. Think of AI like an idea generator. It can surface trends, suggest copy, or repurpose assets. But the best ideas still come from your team’s intuition, insight, and imagination.
- Don’t go all-in on one platform. Relying too heavily on a single AI-powered platform creates dependency. You lose control over your data, your audience relationships, and your negotiation leverage. Stay diversified.
Bottom line: use AI as a tool, not a replacement. Keep people in charge of the message, strategy, creative, and the roll-out. That’s how you get the best of both worlds: machine speed with human insight and oversight.
In Advertising, Balance Beats Autopilot
At True Interactive, we believe in using AI to make marketers smarter, not redundant. The best outcomes come from balancing automation with human oversight, creativity, and strategic judgment. In fact, some of today’s most effective campaigns use AI behind the scenes. But the spark that turns data into story is still human.
So, when Big Tech says, “Let AI do it all,” think twice. The more you delegate to machines, the more you risk losing the very things that make your brand distinctive and trusted.
To learn how to make AI work for your brand without giving up control, reach out to True Interactive. We help clients harness the power of automation without compromising creativity, compliance, or common sense.
Learn more about our paid media and analytics capabilities.
